How to spot a fake Scotty Cameron putter
The price test, the milling and stamping details counterfeiters get wrong, why the headcover proves nothing, and how to buy safely on eBay.
Collectors on Titleist's own forum describe the used market as flooded with fake Scotty Camerons, and the good fakes are hard to tell from the real thing in photos. No single test is proof. Together, these checks catch most of them.
1. The price
Counterfeiters sell below the market because they have to. A current-line putter (Special Select, Super Select, Phantom) offered at half the typical sold price is not a lucky find. Check the putter's page on this site before anything else. A price within the normal range does not prove a putter is real, but a price far below it is the strongest single warning you will get.
2. Milling and stamping
Genuine Cameron heads are milled and stamped cleanly. Things to look at in close, sharp photos:
- The sightline on the topline. Dealers who authenticate putters note that a genuine sightline is cut deeper than on most fakes.
- Lettering on the sole. Fakes often use a thinner or slightly wrong font, with soft or uneven edges.
- Markings that should be there. One authentication guide points to the Titleist mark on the heel side of many models as something counterfeits often leave out. Compare with photos of the same model on the official Scotty Cameron site.
- Paint fill. Sloppy, bleeding or wrong-color paint fill in the stampings is common on fakes.
3. The headcover proves nothing
Fake putters often come with very convincing fake headcovers, and genuine putters are often sold without one. One dealer guide gives a useful tell: a tour-style headcover arriving with a retail putter in a retail-style bag is a strong sign of a fake. Judge the putter, not the cover.
4. Shaft, grip and weight
Retail Camerons come with a specific grip and a shaft band. A putter with an aftermarket grip is not necessarily fake, since many owners change grips, but a putter that feels light, or whose head looks cast rather than milled, is a concern. A local pro shop can often weigh and look at a putter for you.
5. Buying safely
- Buy from sellers with a long record of selling golf equipment, and read negative feedback for "fake" or "counterfeit".
- Pay through the platform. eBay's money-back guarantee covers items that are not as described, which includes counterfeits.
- For high-value putters, especially anything marked Circle T, insist on provenance or use an authentication service.
- If you receive a putter you believe is fake, report it to the platform and to Titleist; do not resell it.